AND deceptively strong — thanks to a cup each of Bailey’s Irish Cream and flavored vodka.. Fireball Whiskey Cheesecake Shots. Made with just 5 ingredients, these chocolate pudding shots are totally delicious. Fireball Pie Shots. Chocolate Pudding Shot Ingredients. Grumpy's Honeybunch. Yields: 1 dozen 12 (2.5 oz) plastic soufflé cups 1 (3 oz) box vanilla instant JELL-O pudding 1 1/4 cups whole milk 3/4 cup vodka - chilled 8 oz tub Cool Whip - thawed Whipped cream, for garnish 1/2 cup Smuckers salted caramel topping (or regular caramel topping) Sea salt - coarse or flaked Instructions. Food Network. Get the recipe here. Candy Cane Pudding Shots – These festive pudding shots are going to be the life of the party! If you like cheesecake instead, here's the Fireball jello shot for you. The original recipe calls for espresso vodka, which sounds fabulous but is about as common as a unicorn around here. Eggnog Pudding Shots – Eggnog Pudding Shots are such a great way to celebrate the season! Scoop a chunk out of the center of the cupcake to make room for the pudding. Honestly, these cheesecake shots are just delightful. Now that you have everything made, it’s time to assemble the cupcakes. 8. It's dessert and a drink all in one, and layered in shot glasses, they're pretty enough to serve as a centerpiece, too. Cream all the ingredients together with an electric mixer and set aside. Irish Whiskey Buttercream – 1 cup butter, softened – 1 teaspoon vanilla – 3 cups powdered sugar – 3 teaspoons Irish Whiskey – 3 tablespoons milk . Salted Caramel Pudding Shots! Ingredients. These boozy little pudding cups are sweet, creamy and pack a nice little punch!